If you’re planning a trip to St. Thomas, chances are you’re excited about beach-hopping, scenic views, and soaking in the island’s tropical charm. But before you grab your keys and hit the road, there’s something most travelers don’t realize:

Renting a car in St. Thomas is nothing like renting a car in the mainland U.S.

From unusual driving rules to surprising terrain, to hidden advantages of choosing the right car rental near me provider there are things locals know that visitors don’t discover until they’re already on the island.

This blog uncovers the 10 most overlooked truths about renting a car hereand how they can make or break your vacation experience.

Let’s get into what every traveler truly needs to know.

1. You Drive on the Left Side of the Road (But the Steering Wheel Is Still on the Left)

This one catches almost every first-time visitor off guard.

St. Thomas drives on the left, but the vehicles are just like those in the U.S. steering wheel on the left side.

It feels strange for the first 20 minutes, but renting the right car gives you better comfort and control when adjusting.

2. You Really Should Book Your Rental Before You Land

Island inventory is limited. During peak seasons, everything gets booked fast.

Many travelers assume they can book at arrival, but that’s one of the biggest mistakes.
Booking ahead ensures:

• better vehicle selection
  
  

• lower rates
  
  

• access to the best car rental deals
  
  

• a smoother airport experience
  
  

Don’t gamble with availability, reserve early.

3. Airport Pickup Saves You Time, Money, and Stress

Cyril E. King Airport is busy, and taxi fares can surprise travelers.

Choosing a car rental st thomas airport provider means:

• no long taxi lines
  
  

• no expensive taxi costs
  
  

• no waiting
  
  

• no delays
  
  

You get your car immediately and start your vacation the moment you step off the plane.

4. The Hills Are Steeper Than You Expect

St. Thomas is full of steep, winding roads and sharp curves.
This is why vehicle choice matters.

Compact cars work well for easy routes, but SUVs, minivans, or Wranglers offer power and stability for:

• Mountain Top
  
  

• Drake’s Seat
  
  

• Northside beaches
  
  

• Scenic overlooks
  
  

If you plan to explore, choose a car that can handle the island’s terrain.

5. Beaches Require More Gear Than You Think Choose Your Vehicle Wisely

Snorkel sets, towels, chairs, coolers, bags, floaties... it adds up.

Visitors often underestimate how much stuff they’ll bring to each beach, only to discover their car is too small.

SUVs and minivans make beach-hopping much easier.

6. Unlimited Mileage Isn’t Optional It’s Essential

St. Thomas may seem small, but once you start exploring:

• Magens Bay
  
  

• Coki Point
  
  

• Sapphire Beach
  
  

• Lindquist
  
  

• Brewers Bay
  
  

• Secret Harbour
  
  

• Coral World
  
  

• Mountain Top
  
  

…the miles add up quickly.

The smartest car rental deals always include unlimited mileage, giving you freedom without worrying about extra fees.

7. Some of the Best Spots Aren’t Taxi-Friendly

Taxis don’t always go to hidden beaches or less touristy areas, such as:

• Hull Bay
  
  

• Neltjeberg
  
  

• Off-the-path scenic lookouts
  
  

Having your own rental means you can explore more, do more, and discover what locals love.

8. Parking Can Be Tight Smaller Cars Have an Advantage in Town

If you're staying near:

• Charlotte Amalie
  
  

• Havensight
  
  

• Frenchtown
  
  

…parking gets crowded. Compact cars shine here.

But for beaches and hills, larger vehicles still offer more comfort.

9. Weather Can Affect Driving Conditions (Another Reason to Choose the Right Car)

Rain can make steep roads slick and visibility low.

This is where SUVs and Wranglers offer better:

• traction
  
  

• grip
  
  

• stability
  
  

Choosing the right car enhances both safety and comfort.

10. Renting a Car Changes Your Entire Vacation Experience

When you have your own vehicle, your trip instantly becomes more flexible and enjoyable.

You can:

• arrive early to beat crowds
  
  

• chase sunsets across the island
  
  

• explore hidden gems
  
  

• stop for photos anytime
  
  

• visit multiple beaches a day
  
  

• travel on your schedule, not a taxi’s
  
  

In St. Thomas, a rental car isn’t a convenience, it’s a vacation game changer.

Bonus Tip: Locals Choose Cars Based on Their Plans—You Should Too

Locals know the island inside out. They choose vehicles based on:

• where they’re going
  
  

• how many people they’re with
  
  

• how much gear they have
  
  

• the weather
  
  

Plan like they do, and your trip becomes smooth, safe, easy, and memorable.

Final Thoughts

The more you know ahead of time, the better your St. Thomas experience will be. Choosing the right car rental st thomas provider, securing early reservations, understanding island driving, and picking the right vehicle shape how much you enjoy your trip.

From airport pickup convenience to exploring beaches without limits to discovering hidden gems, your rental car is the key to unlocking the best of St. Thomas.

Avoid the surprises drive the island like you already belong here.

NAP (Name – Address – Phone)

First Rent-A-Car
8269A, Bournefield, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands
Phone: +1 (340) 776-3730